Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tamara's avatar

Your ability to hold paradox (to dream amid devastation, to create beauty in the shadow of uncertainty) is nothing short of magical in itself. I love Jon’s question — “Is this show a dream or a party?” — because isn’t that exactly what healing asks of us? To throw ourselves into joy, even when the ground is unsteady. To dare to imagine something better, wilder, truer, even as life keeps revising the script.

Your story reminds me of Frida Kahlo painting in bed, body in pieces but spirit ferociously whole. You don’t just endure…. you CREATE. You conjure. You invite us into the sacred mess of it all.

And maybe that’s the idea I’d humbly add: that this isn’t just a book tour, but collective ritual. A way of transmuting fear into meaning, and solitude into solidarity. You’re not just launching a book. You’re launching a reminder that art is what we make when the world breaks, not just before or after.

Thank you for letting us witness the magic behind the curtain, Suleika! We should be holding space for every note, every laugh, every moment of glorious awkwardness that takes the stage.

Expand full comment
Kim.'s avatar

I wasn’t even auditioning. Not really.

A friend suggested it—said I had a good ear, that I could probably hold my own in a chorus. I said maybe, which in my language usually means absolutely not, then fine, but only if no one’s looking.

So I drove myself there, fully expecting a harmless humiliation. Hair brushed. Mildly underprepared. A little thrilled. Mostly, panicked.

The house was intimidating in that moneyed silence sort of way—columns, gates, gravel that tattled on your arrival. The kind of place where even the trees look inherited. I pulled up, already halfway to regretting everything, when I heard it.

This voice—so loud, so flawless—it had to be a recording.

Of course it was. No one sounds like that in real life.

I paused at the car door, stilled by it. Good grief, I thought, is that even human?

The door opened while the voice was still soaring.

A woman greeted me like this was all completely ordinary—opera bellowing through the halls without apology.

“They won’t be long,” she said, as though I was early for lunch.

I followed her in & sat—awkwardly—on the edge of a sofa that looked wildly unsuited to actual use. The music kept going. It was still perfect. I tried not to fidget. Or shrink. Or scream.

Then the music stopped.

A silence followed that felt strangely final, like the ceiling had taken a breath.

And from somewhere down the hallway, a voice called out:

“Anthony, that was magnificent.”

Magnificent.

The word thudded into the room like a chandelier crashing.

My stomach turned traitor. My heart tried to exit via my throat.

That hadn’t been a recording. That had been live.

That had been Anthony.

A person. Singing. In real time. While I casually sat two rooms away like I was waiting for my dentist appointment.

I stood. Slowly. Light-headed.

Briefly considered fleeing.

No one knew I was here. I could vanish. Slide out the front door, never look back.

But fate—ever theatrical—had already lifted the curtain.

The double doors opened like something out of a dream sequence—just without the part where I wake up. Anthony emerged, glowing. As if singing like that hadn’t cost him a single breath.

He gave me a brief, polite nod. I returned it in the way one might acknowledge royalty or a slow-moving disaster.

And then he appeared.

Alexander. Tall. Unblinking. Impeccably assembled.

He had the presence of someone who expects music to obey him, & the wardrobe of someone who’s never spilled anything in his life.

Without introduction or even a hello, he gestured to the piano.

I followed. Like a sheep. Or a sacrifice.

We did scales.

Well—he played scales. I made sounds that resembled commitment. My voice, to its credit, did its best to pretend it had done this before.

I tried to stand like someone capable. Tried to breathe like it wasn’t my first time meeting oxygen.

Alexander said nothing.

Not a flicker of encouragement. No sign that I was bombing or triumphing. Just clinical silence.

Then, mid-note, he stood.

And walked out.

No “thank you.” No “that’ll do.” Not even a vague grunt of dismissal.

Just… gone.

I remained, mouth slightly open, perched in front of the piano like an abandoned prop.

Then came Marguerite.

She entered like punctuation—sharp, deliberate, & slightly scented with judgement.

She was clearly cast as ‘Woman Who Does Not Share the Stage,’ & had no interest in improvisation.

And then, from somewhere deep within the house, Alexander’s voice rang out:

“Show her.”

That was it. No context. Just a command tossed down like a gauntlet.

A piece of paper was placed in my hands.

Italian. Of course.

Not a word I could understand, but it looked serious—italic font, composer’s name I couldn’t pronounce. The kind of sheet music that doesn’t ask if you’re ready. It assumes you are.

Alexander reappeared, glanced at me like I was a mildly disappointing soufflé, & said:

“Follow me.”

So I did.

Because by then, I’d given up on logic & was simply responding to tone of voice.

Here’s the part that still baffles me.

I wasn’t laughed out. No one patted my hand or gently suggested I take up something more forgiving, like pottery.

They offered me a role.

A mezzo-soprano gal in the chorus.

But before that—

“Brava.”

I turned, assuming it was meant for Marguerite.

She looked like someone who’d be applauded just for existing.

But it wasn’t for her.

It was Anthony.

The Anthony.

He’d come back in. Quietly. Sat down. Stayed.

And he was looking at me.

“Brava,” he said again.

Then, as if it were the most obvious thing in the world:

“You have a voice that needs to be sung.”

I don’t remember what I said next.

I don’t even remember leaving the room.

Even to this day, I still don’t know how I made it back to my car.

All I know is I sat there, white-knuckling the steering wheel,

having absolutely no idea what had just happened—

& a sudden craving for tiramisu to face-plant into.

I’m still sweating as I recount this.

Bemused.

Utterly.

And can I just say—how much I love the word subsumed.

Thank you for using it in your essay today, Suleika.

And for this remembrance.

Expand full comment
143 more comments...

No posts